|

Archive
Oct.
26 - Last
week, I said no other weekly magazine covers college football
as well as The Sporting News. I may have to amend that statement
to "no other weekly magazine covers football as well
as The Sporting News," after this week's excellent issue.
However, if
you want World Series coverage, you better look elsewhere.
TSN, though,
does serve the football world well this week. It has terrific articles
on the recent success of return men in the NFL and on a football
weekend in Texas. It also gives insightful analysis on the Redskins
mess, the Kerry Collins controversy and college football's Bowl
Championship Series.
If you are
a football fan, you will enjoy this issue.
Phil Barber
examines why runback specialists are having so much success this
year in the NFL. He notes two obvious reasons - free agency and
better returners - but he also points out two not-so-obvious reasons.
First, bigger and stronger kickers and punters are outkicking
the coverage. Second, officials are ignoring the holding
call in the middle of the field.
The story also
breaks down "the perfect return" - Raven returner Jermaine
Lewis' 87-yard touchdown return against the Bengals. This was a
great return to feature not only because it was "perfect"
but also because the game was on ESPN so many football fans may
have seen it. TSN does a nice job breaking it down; however, it
really is something that is easier to analyze on television than
on paper. Although TSN does it as well as you can do on paper.
This piece
definitely helps readers "see a different game."
Bill Minutaglio
describes life on the weekend in football-crazy Texas. He focuses
not on the game but on the atmosphere around it. He starts with
six-man games on Friday nights and ends with the Cowboys on Sunday.
Whether you are from Texas or not, football fans will enjoy this
treat.
I thought the
best part was its look at Josh Cuttill's "job" at Texas
A&M, which is to update the score for six dead dogs. Excellent
work and excellent timing because Minutaglio covered Cuttill
during the Nebraska-Texas A&M game, which the Aggies won.
Paul Attner
discusses how Redskin coach Norv Turner was "dragged down by
ineptness at the one position he could flat-out coach," while
Dan Pompei answers all the questions in the Kerry Collins controversy.
Pompei covers the Collins situation better than the Sunday pregame
shows did last week. Finally, Tom Dienhart and Mike Huguenin
examines the most intriguing aspect of the Bowl Championship Series,
strength of schedule.
After you get
through all that, then readers have 15 more pages of team notes
and stats for the NFL and six additional pages of notes and stats
for college football.
It's almost
an indigestible amount of football coverage. Fortunately, many football
fans have big appetites and bigger waistlines.
As for the other
stuff in the issue, TSN's baseball coverage was better this week
with Michael Knisley's solid look at the first two World Series
games. And I continue to enjoy Astros manager Larry Dierker's analysis.
Dierker's piece
actually contains a line you don't see too much in U.S. publications:
"I'd like to see us think more like they do in Cuba."
He was referring to Cuban baseball officials ignoring pitch counts,
while coaches at all levels in the U.S. put too much emphasis on
it.
My only question
is why just four pages of coverage, which begins on page 53 of
the 70-page issue? I know it's tough for the weeklies because
by the time readers get the issue, two or three more games have
been played since the stories were written. In this case, games
three and four were played.
In playoff series
like this, the weeklies should challenge themselves to offer timely,
insightful coverage - instead of just settling for the minimum,
which is what TSN did this week.
Interesting
note: NHL writer Helene Elliott writes about Vancouver in her
NHL column. Two pages later, Keenan's weekly "Inside the Game"
piece appears. I highly doubt that Keenan's weekly column influenced
Elliott's, but I just found it interesting.
Grade: A-.
Can we start calling TSN the bible of football? (George)
Back
to top
Oct.
19
- No other weekly magazine covers college football as
well as The Sporting News, which devoted 12 full pages to the
sport in this week's issue.
The first four
pages were for its midseason report, which contained the usual lists
of biggest surprises, biggest disappointments and awards picks.
It also includes TSN's prediction that Ohio State will beat UCLA
in the Fiesta Bowl for the National Championship.
The pick isn't
exactly like having "immoral relations" in the Oval Office,
considering Ohio State and UCLA are Nos. 1 and 2, respectively;
however, the overall midseason report was a good, especially
for those who have been too busy with baseball to keep up with college
football.
The other eight
college football pages is TSN's weekly look at the sport. When you
compare the amount of information packed into these pages each week
with the college football coverage in Sports Illustrated and ESPN,
it's like comparing Ohio State to Oregon State.
As for the other
articles, TSN tried to decipher the playbook terminology used in
the NFL. I found the story disappointing because I didn't come
away with a better understanding of the language used. There
is a lot about how confusing it could be, especially to those who
have played on many teams or under many coaches, but I think most
football fans already realize the complexity of play-calling in
the NFL.
I would have
liked to have seen a list of common terms and their definitions
as well as more about the "etymology" of the words used
and the development of play-calling.
Finally, TSN's
baseball playoff coverage still wasn't up to Sports Illustrated's
high standards, especially its look at the American League Championship
Series, which I thought was woefully under-reported and uninsightful.
Especially for a series where so much happened.
I do, however,
enjoy Larry Dierker's columns, which I find very honest.
However,
the best piece of the issue is basketball writer Dave D'Alessandro's
highly critical state of the union and owners in the NBA. He
blames both for not trying harder to fix the mess they both have
created. Good stuff, I just hope the mentioned parties find the
commentary buried on page 67.
Grade: B-. Baseball
coverage is keeping the former bible down. (George)
Back
to top
Oct.
12
- For those of us who spend most of our waking hours watching
and consuming sports, we know a lot about "speed." Speed
kills. You can't teach speed. Speed II stinks.
But I've got
another one for you: It's hard to cover speed on paper, which
is exactly what The Sporting News tried to do this week, devoting
17 pages to the topic.
The best
part of the special section easily is a look at how quickly Warren
Sapp rushes the quarterback. Paul Attner does an excellent job
bringing readers on the field and giving them an idea of how fast
Sapp must be to sack a quarterback. Basically, Attner says, Sapp
must run five yards, get by someone as big if not bigger than him
and reach the quarterback in three seconds.
Or in shorter
time than it probably took you to read the past two sentences.
TSN also effectively
proved that football teams probably shave some tenths of a second
off players' 40 times.
As for other
the sports, the magazine did a decent job analyzing how a 100-mile-per-hour
fastball is viewed by the pitcher, catcher, batter and umpire,
but its pieces on the slap shot in hockey and a fast break in basketball
are uninsightful and inferior to the rest of the section.
Overall, with
the exception of Attner's story, I didn't come away with any greater
insight on speed. That's not to blame TSN because it is a difficult
subject to write about, and I don't know how I would have done things
differently.
I certainly
give the magazine credit for trying something different and challenging;
unfortunately, it pulled up lame on its lofty goals.
As for the other
stories: Joe Posnanski's profile of Kansas State coach Bill Snyder
is a must-read. Posnanski, a columnist for the Kansas City Star,
says Snyder's attention to detail has led to the miraculous turnaround
at Kansas State. "No coach in America, perhaps, has so much
control of every part of the football program," Posnanski writes.
Readers will
come away with a better appreciation of Snyder's hard work at Manhattan.
TSN also previews
the two League Championship Series in a satisfactory manner.
Grade:
B-, Writing about speed is like beating Nebraska in Lincoln - one
can do it, but everything has to go just right. (George)
Back
to top
Oct.
5
- Associate Editor Tom Dienhart's view from inside the
Kentucky film room is, by far, the best story in this week's
The Sporting News. Dienhart sits in with coach Hal Mumme and
quarterback Tim Couch as they go over their game plan against Florida.
Of course, the reader knows the outcome (Florida won 51-35), but
it is still very interesting to follow the development of a game
plan from before, during and after the game.
Anyone who
has an interest in the X's and O's of football - whether pro or
college - will really enjoy this story. Kudos to Dienhart for
getting permission from Kentucky to do this type of article and
for turning it around so quickly to make the piece timely and interesting.
Kudos also to Kentucky for opening up its film room to TSN.
Kudos to everyone!
This week's
issue is also the NHL Preview, which will probably disappoint
hard-core hockey fans but will be enough to satisfy the average
sports fan. (It should be noted that The Sporting News has a
separate NHL yearbook on newsstands now.)
TSN follows
a brief article on how the league is trying to boost scoring with
standard preseason lists, such as what teams will, may or won't
contend for the Stanley Cup. The magazine also looks into its
“Crystal Ball” (no doubt on loan from our NFL Guru) and predicts
that Detroit will beat Philadelphia in the Stanley Cup Finals.
For the record,
in its Preseason Power Poll, TSN ranks Detroit No. 1; Dallas No.
2; and Philadelphia No. 3. At the other end, it has Tampa Bay No.
25; Florida No. 26; and Nashville No. 27.
TSN also previews
each NHL club, devoting a third of a page to each team analyzing
its good news, bad news, player on the spot and bottom line. While
fans will probably learn little new about their favorite team, it
is a decent primer to catch up on the other teams.
What’s weird
is that Mike Keenan is “an exclusive NHL analyst” for The Sporting
News. He’s also coach of Vancouver. Is this a conflict of interest?
Can Keenan manipulate his column to the Canucks benefit? Can TSN
fairly report on Vancouver? (TSN ranks them No. 18 in the Power
Poll.)
Can you think
of another instance where an active coach also served as an analyst
for a major sports magazine or television show during the season?
Let me know if you do.
This certainly
will be something to watch as the season progresses.
The cover story
about baseball’s final week is a lot of fluff. And worse than
that, it is old fluff.
Oh, isn’t
great that McGwire hit 70? ...
How cute,
the Cubbies made the playoffs. ...
There is nothing
new or noteworthy in the story, which certainly doesn’t make
you “see a different game” as the magazine promises to do each
week.
This week’s
Kentucky story makes you see a different game. Last
week’s Rod Woodson piece made you see a different game. This
week’s baseball story? Nope.
Speaking of
the Woodson article, this week’s issue also includes a look at the
recent NFL trend to taller cornerbacks. The article is alright,
but it seems like it should have gone with last week’s Woodson feature,
especially because there is no time element to it. Was it pushed
back a week because of space or is it just a coincidence that TSN
did major pieces on cornerbacks in back-to-back weeks?
Grade:
B, the Kentucky piece is excellent, the NHL Preview is OK and the
baseball story stinks. (George)
Back
to top
Sept.
28
-This week’s The Sporting News advertises itself as baseball’s
“Playoffs Preview,” but Paul Attner’s piece on Baltimore Ravens
cornerback Rod Woodson steals the issue. It is easily the
best feature I’ve read recently in TSN.
Attner does
a wonderful job showing how Woodson, a future Hall of Famer and
all-time NFL great, is trying to rebuild his image as one of the
league’s best cornerbacks after a subpar year in 1997 with the San
Francisco 49ers. As Attner points out, Woodson can retire now and
still not lose his overall place in NFL history as one of the game’s
best; however, he marches on - separated from his family - using
intelligence and experience to camouflage deteriorating physical
skills.
Attner retraces
the decisions made by both Woodson and the Ravens that led to No.
26 signing with the team. He details the concerns the Ravens
had about Woodson’s body and about public perception. He lets Woodson
explain why things didn’t work out with the 49ers and why he is
more comfortable with the Raven and the AFC Central.
The story also
shows how Woodson is trying to be a mentor to the younger, talented
members of the Ravens defense.
And then, the
coup de grace is a sidebar on how much Woodson studies film to prepare
for games. Fortunately for Attner, he catches Woodson studying
for the Jets game in week two. Woodson tells Attner what he
is learning about the Jets from watching the film and how he is
going to use this knowledge in the game. Well, Woodson gets an A
for his studies because he intercepted two passes in the game -
one for a touchdown - and received player of the week honors.
Attner deserves
writer of the week honors for this insightful look at Woodson
and the Ravens.
As for the playoffs
preview, the cover led me to believe that it was going to be
more expansive, although it wasn’t bad. The New York Post’s
Jay Greenberg examines the five-game divisional series, which scares
teams with better regular-season records because there is less leeway
for failure. But, as Greenberg notes, the 1997 Yankees are the only
team with a better record to have lost a divisional series since
it began in 1995.
Then, he confusingly
adds that in the 18 divisional and League Championship series since
1995, “teams with better regular-season records have gone 12-5-1,
hardly suggesting carnage left by a crapshoot.” What is the tie
for? Did I miss a five- or seven-game series that ended in a tie?
Is he using the tie to signify that one series involved teams with
an equal record? If so, he could have written that more clearly,
such as “teams with better regular-season records have gone 12-5,
hardly suggesting carnage left by a crapshoot. (One series involved
teams with equal records).”
TSN also
ranks the 12 playoff-possible teams (including the Blue Jays,
Mets, Cubs and Giants) in eight different categories - lineups,
manager/coaches, bench, secret weapon, momentum, starting pitching,
relief pitching and defense. The lists go as you would suspect,
although I disagree with some rankings. Bobby Cox is a better manager
than Joe Torre and everyone else? The Rangers have a better lineup
than the Yankees? The Braves a better bullpen than the Indians?
Of course, debates
like that are what makes lists interesting for fans.
This issue also
includes looks at UCLA quarterback Cade McNown, of which much has
been done already by others, and LSU running back Kevin Faulk, of
which more needs to be done. Both, though, are very good reads,
especially the Faulk article.
And, as always,
you have the bevy of notes, stats and team-by-team information
that makes The Sporting News unique.
Grade:
A-. It is one of the best TSN’s that I have read in a while.
Back
to top
Sept.
21
- The former "Bible of Baseball" has sinned.
A mortal sin.
Worse than the
president. ... O.K., maybe not that bad.
But this week's
The Sporting News, labeled a "special collectors issue," deifies
Mark McGwire and ignores Sammy Sosa. The issue is poorly
laid out, and the McGwire tribute is overdone and way-too-reverential.
Other than that,
though, the issue was O.K. But that's like saying that other than
being fat Gilbert Brown is in good shape.
It seems that,
like Major League Baseball, TSN was caught with its jock strap down
last weekend. Except for the words "along with Sammy Sosa" on pages
4 and 15; a paragraph on the difference in race between the two
players on page 22; and a chart tracking their home runs on pages
46 and 42 (more on that later), TSN did not mention Sammy Sosa
or his 62nd home run in a news story until PAGE 67!
And many readers
may have missed that Sosa story because there is no mention of the
three-quarters-of-a-page story on the cover, in the table of contents,
in the McGwire article or at the centerfold.
To be fair
to TSN, Sosa's historic homers - he hit Nos. 61 and 62 on Sunday
to help the Cubs win 11-10 in 10 innings - came at deadline.
TSN editorial director John Rawlings said each week “is constantly
a balancing act” of cramming as much news as possible but making
sure the magazine gets out in a timely manner for subscribers.
For example,
Rawlings said, by the time Sosa hit his homers late Sunday afternoon,
the magazine already had finished the cover, which is due by noon
CDT Sunday. Any changes to the cover at that point could have delayed
delivery of the magazine another 24 hours.
Certainly, then,
timing played a major role in how TSN covered McGwire and Sosa's
achievements, but it doesn't exonerate the 112-year-old magazine.
While both men were tied Monday morning at 62 homers each, TSN’s
coverage of McGwire blew Sosa away.
For McGwire's
62 home runs, TSN gave him the cover, the "From The Editor," a 12-page
special section with the headline "American Hero" and a four-page
centerfold that included charts, a poster (for newsstand editions
only) and a centerfold picture.
Sosa, for his
62 homers, received a 750-word story buried with no fanfare on page
67.
Holy cow, what
a country!
As Rawlings
said, if he knew Wednesday what was going to happen Sunday, then
the coverage may have been different. Obviously, McGwire helped
The Sporting News out by hitting his 62 homer on Tuesday, early
enough in the magazine’s work week to plan something special. And
one certainly can’t blame the magazine for not being able to predict
correctly the future. Hell, I can barely pick one
out of three college football games correctly.
But you can
blame TSN for not being ready in case Sosa got hot.
Just like baseball
wasn’t prepared with the specially marked baseballs, TSN wasn’t
ready to cover Sosa in case he tied or went ahead of McGwire. Knowing
that it was going to spend so much attention on McGwire, it probably
would have been a good precaution for TSN to have something or somebody
ready in case Sosa tied or went ahead. The page 67 story is a weak
attempt because it devotes only a third of the article to the achievement,
with the other two-thirds focusing on his impact on the Latin American
players.
Rawlings, though,
disagreed, saying McGwire clearly was the focus.
“There just
wasn’t the public interest in Sosa when he hit 62 because it had
already been done once.” He added that he doesn’t second guess
his decisions for this issue.
But won’t Cubs
and Sosa fans feel slighted?
“I’m sure they
will,” Rawlings said.
But besides
its Sosa preparations, TSN also should be charged with an error
for planning to devote all that space to McGwire with only fleeting
mentions of Sosa. That decision is an insult to Sosa and his
achievements, whether he was at 59, 60, 61 or 62. One could argue
that McGwire might not have reached the record without some prodding
and kidding from Sosa.
(It should be
noted that TSN had a two-page article on McGwire and Sosa each last
week. To see ArmchairQB.com’s review of that issue, click
here)
Rawlings
said the magazine isn’t planning anything special right now for
Sosa. The editorial director said it will wait until the season
is over, see who ends up getting the record and then decide how
to handle it.
I just hope
that whatever TSN chooses that it takes a different approach to
the article. The 12-page McGwire article, which isn’t as
long as it sounds because the pages are filled with interesting
graphics and pictures, is way too reverential. It was trying
to show how and why McGwire is a hero but goes a little overboard
with the platitudes. Plus, so many other media outlets - with a
week headstart on TSN - already had well-documented his generosity,
his love for his son and his respect for the game.
But, at times,
this week’s story seemed sweeter than a bowl full of saccharine.
For example,
after spending a paragraph saying McGwire is not perfect because
of his use and defense of androstenedione, the next paragraph begins
with this: “We question that blind spot, yet, perversely, find him
more appealing because of it, in the way Cindy Crawford’s mole accents
her beauty.”
What? How can
you compare McGwire taking a supplement that is banned in the NFL,
NCAA and Olympics, and can be very risky, to a nonharmful, arguably
sexy mark on a model’s face? For that matter, how can you even compare
McGwire to a model? No offense, Mark, I love looking at your swing
but...
Overall,
though, the McGwire story lacks any original perspective and is
not insightful.
Finally, the
layout for McGwire is odd. Usually, TSN does a nice job of keeping
all the articles about a certain sport together; this way, for example,
one doesn’t have to jump around the magazine to read all the baseball
stories. This week, the magazine didn’t do that. It had the 12-page
special section in the beginning; the four-page centerfold and poster
in, take a guess, the center; and the baseball news and notes in
the second half.
The centerfold
actually divides the magazine’s weekly two-page look at the NFC
East in half, with Arizona and Dallas on the first page and
New York, Philadelphia and Washington on the page after all the
centerfold stuff.
It seems the
easy thing to have done would be to place all the baseball stuff
around the centerfold, which has pictures of McGwire on the inside
two pages and graphs and charts on the back two pages. A chart tracking
McGwire and Sosa’s home runs takes up more than one page; unfortunately,
though, TSN starts the chart on page 46 and ends it on page 42.
That means readers who peruse the magazine in numerical order will
see the end of the chart on page 42 - right next to the Cowboy team
notes - before knowing what it is about. There had to be a better
way than starting the chart on a page farther ahead and working
back.
By the way,
Rawlings said the magazine did the poster (again only for newsstand
editions) because it wanted to do something out of the ordinary
inside - especially after seeing the extra edition that Sports Illustrated
did last week - and still capture the emotion of the moment.
Quickly on
the other articles: David Climer’s story on Tee Martin is
the best of the bunch because the two-page story covers all
of Martin’s main points about his rough off-the-field background
and delayed on-the-field career. ... Michael Bradley’s body-part-by-body-part
look at Daunte Culpepper is decent, except his lead is slightly
incorrect. “Now that Peyton Manning and Ryan Leaf are learning
that big contracts and lofty draft status don’t guarantee immediate
NFL success...” Leaf is 2-0 so far this season - you can’t get more
successful than that. Bradley certainly wrote it before the second
game and maybe even before the first, just assuming that Leaf and
Manning would struggle.
SI Shot:
In the comment next to the Detroit Tigers, ranked 29th out of 30th
in TSN’s Power Poll, the magazine writes “Remember when some other
mag called Easley the best 2B in the game today?” In its July 6
magazine, Sports Illustrated named Easley the second baseman on
its first half Dream Team in a story headlined “All-Stars ... So
Far.” At the time, he was batting .292 with 19 homers and 58 runs
batted in. In TSN’s Sept. 21 issue, approximately 10 weeks later,
he is listed as batting .274 with 22 homers and 88 RBI.
Grade:
C-. It will be interesting to see how The Sporting News covers Sosa
in the next few weeks. (George)
Back
to top
Sept.
14
- The features in this week’s The Sporting News are weak.
There is little new or exciting in the McGwire and Sosa stories.
(TSN should read recent issues of Sports Illustrated, which has
done an excellent job covering the home run chase this summer, to
see how to cover McGwire well on a weekly basis.)
Meanwhile, the
Jets-49ers game story was like a rookie starting his first NFL -
it tried to do too much. It begins by suggesting that fans
can expect to see a lot of high-scoring, high-octane games like
the 49ers’ 36-30 win in the NFL this year. However, after seven
paragraphs setting up that thesis, the rest of the article focuses
solely on the 49ers and the game. By splitting the article between
the NFL and the 49ers, neither topic is covered satisfactorily.
The issue also
has a ho-hum story ranking the top 100 NFL players based
on current skills (i.e. forgetting the player’s past and ignoring
his future). I didn’t have any major problems with the list (although
it was a bit disconcerting to see Dan Marino at No. 93), but I did
have a major problem with timing. This kind of list, which was composed
by surveying NFL team executives, would have been extremely helpful
to NFL rotisserie players two weeks ago. Now, it is nothing
more than a debate starter.
A college football
story examining four major games from last weekend and their influence
on the Bowl Championship Series was solid. But other than that college
football piece, the other features were disappointing in
one way or another.
But despite
that, The Sporting News is still necessary reading because of its
excellent notes sections. No other magazine consistently
gives you the insight, review and statistics on each team like TSN.
So even on weak weeks, TSN is good read.
For example,
TSN this week tells you the young and old players each baseball
team is looking at this September for roster spots next year. It
also predicts some of what you can expect from each team in the
offseason. Sure, most people aren’t going to have the time to read
each team’s notes, but having the ability to read about any team
you want (in either baseball or the NFL) separates TSN from the
other two main weekly sports magazines.
Also, TSN
covers college football better than the other two magazines
and its college football wrap-up is necessary reading for Saturday
football fans, especially those with a college football column on
a web site!
Grade:
B-, we’ve seen better from TSN, but sports fans should never completely
ignore it. (George)
Back
to top
Sept.
7 --
TSN's NFL preview issue offers an excellent Paul Attner article
about Detroit's Barry Sanders, accurately described as the anti-Rodman.
This piece is the first Sanders article I've read that goes deep
into the star's past and examines his strong family roots. Not surprisingly,
we learn that the humble running back was raised to exude humility
and class.
Attner does an exquisite job of showing us the man behind
the spectacular spin moves and eye-popping statistics. Watching
Sanders, it's hard not to view him as a freak, born to dominate
the football world. Thankfully, TSN's refreshing work shows us a
man who happens to play football, not a man whose life is defined
by the game.
TSN's Joe Posnanski focuses on the off-season moves of the Kansas
City Chiefs and examines whether recent acquisitions Chester McGlockton,
Derrick Alexander and Leslie O'Neal can lead Marty Schottenheimer
to the promised land. In a separate article, Dan Pompei writes that
such a Chiefs advance is unlikely without a good running back.
Pompei's potpourri column, with rankings of best units at each position,
is interesting and will spark some debate. He picks the Niners to
win the Super Bowl. San Francisco is also the TSN staff's consensus
pick.
Speaking of the 49ers, former coach Bill Walsh makes his debut as
TSN's football analyst, boldly predicting that he wouldn't be
surprised if Arizona quarterback Jake Plummer was MVP. Slow
down big fella, are you trying to "Beano Cook" this kid?
I'm referring, of course, to ESPN analyst Cook's assertion several
years ago that Notre Dame QB Ron Powlus would win multiple Heisman
Trophies. As waiver wire-watchers know, Powlus was recently cut
by the Tennessee Oilers and now couldn't get a starting job at his
old Berwick, Pa., high school.
Walsh doesn't pick a Super Bowl winner but expects the Broncos to
repeat as AFC Champion and predicts Ryan Leaf will be rookie of
the year.
The team previews are well done with two pages devoted to each division.
Schedules and position-by-position grades are also provided for
each team. Like TSN's Football Preview magazine, this section is
done the right way, by beat writers who actually cover the teams
they are writing about.
TSN also finds time for an interesting college football story, "Prelude
to a Play," by Terry Frei. In a lengthy article, Frei details each
offensive move from the time the quarterback calls a play in the
huddle until the play is executed.
As a former college offensive lineman, I found the piece interesting.
This article also would appeal to the average fan who usually follows
the ball during play and doesn't know what goes in to making each
play work. Good job by Frey of talking to each component of Ohio
State's offensive in writing this article.
The long baseball feature, Michael Knisley's "September Song"
didn't do much for me. Knisley's premise, that September pennant-race
baseball is more heart-pounding than October action, makes some
sense but the article just doesn't connect.
Still, Knisley makes a keen observation when discussing the Cubs'
wild-card chances, saying "September is to Wrigley Field what October
is to Fenway Park." Ouch! (Randy)
Back
to top
August
31 -- TSN's
cover asks "Are the Bucs Ready for the Bowl?" and Chris
Jenkins' article about Tampa Bay quarterback Trent Dilfer says the
fifth-year passer is the key to the team's title hopes.
Despite their
1997 playoff appearance, the Bucs were last in the league in passing
yards. Dilfer isn't totally to blame, Jenkins writes, noting that
he has never played with a competent group of wide receivers. Perhaps
the recent additions of Bert Emanuel and Jacquez Green will provide
a remedy.
"Duck," Steve Marantz's story about the impact of line
drives on the health of major league pitchers is a well-written
story, though not necessarily timely.
True, Houston's Billy Wagner and Baltimore's Mike Mussina have survived
vicious shots to the head this season, but what about the playoff
races? The Angels and Rangers are battling in the AL West and the
Cubs, Giants and Mets are battling for the wild-card in an exhilirating
National League race.
Don't get me wrong. I liked the concept of Marantz's article and
he is an excellent baseball writer but TSN clearly dropped the ball
here.
On the other hand, Kevin Sherrington's article about Texas A&M
linebacker Dat Nguyen is timely, as the Aggies opened Monday against
Florida State in the Kickoff Classic in East Rutherford, N.J. (to
see George's game review, click
here).
Sherrington tells an interesting tale about Nguyen (pronounced win),
describing how the Vietnam native has defeated adversity since his
family fled Siagon in 1975. Nguyen's parents were astonished colleges
would even consider paying for their son's education to play football
and his father said "Honestly, you can't be that good."
Now, Dat is a favorite to win the Butkus Award, which is given to
the nation's top linebacker.
Speaking of awards, oft-decorated columnist Dave Kindred pens a
touching tribute to sportwriting's greatest talent, recently deceased
Los Angeles Times icon Jim Murray. In "He Kept the Calliope
Playing," Kindred writes that Murray's unique humor "rose
from a foundation of knowledge, decency and common sense."
Well done. (Randy)
Back
to top
August 24
-- Not much happening in this lackluster issue. The best article
is Steve Marantz's look at Nebraska's new coach, Frank Solich. While
this has been a well-covered topic, Marantz examines Solich and
his predecessor, Tom Osborne, from his perspective as a former Nebraskan.
Marantz predicts short-term doom for Solich, i.e. two losses, but
long term success.
A
good line from the story: "Nebraskans are fair-minded and patient
people. They'll put up with almost anything as long as it includes
an all-you-can-eat buffet."
This
issue also includes a highly disappointing interview with
baseball's new (sic) commissioner, Bud Selig. The article, which
is solely in Selig's voice, similar to ESPN magazine's stories with
Ken Griffey Jr. and Michael Jordan, lacks any news value. Selig
is just spouting off about what is great about baseball this season
(all the obvious choices) and what needs fixing (such as eliminating
acrimony between players, owners and umpires; furthering realignment;
and reducing disparity among team payrolls).
The
problem is Selig is never challenged to offer solutions or possible
solutions to these already acknowledged problems. The commish just
states that they are problems that need fixing. I could have done
that!
Other
stories include a ho-hum Yankees article, where the main gist seems
to be that Yanks would need to win the World Series before they
are considered a great team, no matter what they do in the regular
season. News Flash! However, it does include an interesting segment
where Rangers manager Johnny Oates compares the Yanks to the 1976
Big Red Machine position-by-position. The Reds win, although Marantz
notes that the Yanks starting pitching is better. .
There
are also looks at the NFC East quarterbacks and Daylon McCutcheon/USC,
but neither of which are particularly memorable or insightful.
My
suggestion: Spend the time this week reading some NFL or college
preview magazines. (George)
Back
to top
August
17
-- In
this week's double issue, The Sporting News presents "The Best
of College Football." But unless you look carefully, you might
miss most of the magazine's picks because they are scrolled along
the bottom of its conference previews pages. TSN gives no reason
or description for the picks, which will probably leave many readers
wondering what, for example, the walk through "The Grove"
is at Mississippi and why is it chosen as TSN's best pregame ritual.
There
were three best categories that TSN did feature. The magazine had
an average article on Ricky Williams, whom it calls "the embodiment
of what's great about college football." We've
read better articles on the much-publicized Texas running back.
But
there was a well-done piece on Virginia Coach George Welsh, who
the magazine - in a SI-like move - calls the "the best coach
in college football today." Yes, Welsh is an excellent coach
who did a remarkable job turning around a program that was one known
as the "Cadavaliers," but he has never won an outright
conference title, let alone a national title. And, he has had some
quality teams recently at Virginia. Really, is he better than Penn
St.'s Joe Paterno? Florida St.'s Bobby Bowden? Or even BYU's LaVell
Edwards? It seems like TSN is pulling a Sports Illustrated -make
a surprising statement, defend it well and see how readers react.
This
week's college football preview doesn't have team previews - I guess
that's what TSN's yearbook is for - but it does have an excellent
note section to prepare you for the season in the "Campus stroll"
as well as a provocative piece on Florida's linebacker Jevon Kearse.
Steve Harrison's article describes how Kearse emerged from a family
with "a history of violence and tragedy" to become, as
TSN calls him, the best defensive player in the nation.
Overall,
if you wanted a good college football preview, I would suggest TSN's
yearbook instead of solely this week's magazine. But if you are
looking for something to compliment the preview magazine you already
have, this week's issue isn't a bad choice.
Besides
college football, the magazine also has a terrific article by Scott
Fowler on the rebuilding of the Carolina Panthers. The article includes
this great lede: "Sean Gilbert won't be enough."
One
quibble: In Steve Marantz's look at the "golden age at
short," he says Cleveland Indians shortstop Omar Vizquel looks
like a Hall of Famer to him. What? Vizquel is the best defensive
shortstop in the game with an underappreciated bat, but he is not
a Hall of Famer. There are many shortstops - Larry Bowa comes quickly
to mind - with similar (albeit reduced) defensive skills but better
offensive numbers than Vizquel. (George)
Back
to top
August 10 -- This week's issue shows
why The Sporting News is the avid baseball fan's best friend. Michael
Knisley writes a very nice article about major trades moves but
the clincher is TSN's breakdown of every deal that occurred before
the Aug. 7 deadline. Great work here.
Kevin Baxter does a good job in profiling baseball player agent
Joe Cubas, giving the reader both sides of the story. Baxter describes
how some see Cubas as a savior while others depict him as a pariah.
One major league scouting executive says "He's made himself
to Cuban baseball basically what Don King is to the fight game."
Wow.
The other noteworthy feature is Scott Pitoniak's "Hope Floats,"
about new Buffalo Bills quarterback Rob Johnson. Johnson says his
low-key attitude isn't due to a lack of competitiveness, adding
that he "can't be Jim Kelly." A short sidebar story about
backup quarterback Doug Flutie is a nice complement.
The most interesting non-feature is NFL columnist Dan Pompei's contention
that Barry Sanders' numbers may soon start to decline. Pompei says
Sanders won't be able to compensate for a loss of quickness like
great athletes in another sport, such as Michael Jordan, who forsakes
the slashing drives to the basket for the jump shot. We'll see.
(Randy)
Back to top
August
3 -- America's oldest sports publication, TSN is also the most
comprehensive with extensive coverage of each of the four major
sports.
Imagine my surprise when I opened my copy and, on pages three and
four, was a giant advertisement for ESPN’s Sportscenter. As Dan
Patrick might say, “You can’t stop Disney. You can only hope to
contain it.”
This week’s issue features an intriguing interview with two pitching
megastars of the past and present - Bob Gibson and Curt Schilling.
Unlike many ballplayers of today, Schilling is well-educated about
the game’s history, an awareness that shows as he recites Gibson’s
stats like he’s reading them off the back of a baseball card.
Likewise, Gibson also seems impressed with the Phillies hurler.
You won’t be surprised when Gibson talks of his disdain for the
media but you might be surprised as to why. Don’t miss this article.
After TNT and NBC announced they will consider forming a football
league to rival the NFL, many scoffed. But, TSN’s Chris Jenkins
says the plans of Ted Turner and Dick Ebersol might not be as farfetched
as you think.
Both networks have deep pockets and would be able to throw big dollars
at some of the NFL’s free agents. Remember, the USFL once signed
Steve Young, Doug Flutie, Herschel Walker, Doug Williams and Reggie
White.
The league would be operated from a central office and Turner and
NBC would control every aspect, including signing players to contracts.
Read this story and you just may emerge less skeptical about the
chances for such a scheme to work. But would it truly be Must See
TV?
The issue also features an article about the off-season struggles
of Terry Bowden's Auburn football and program and, what else, three
stories/columns about Les Bulls. The most interesting story is Dave
Kindred’s piece about Jerry Krause, “The Architect.”
Reading about the masterful moves Krause has made, I was reminded
of a recent caller on a New York sports radio station. “If Krause
were 6-foot-2 with blond hair and blue eyes, he’d be known as a
genius,” he said. Methinks he may be right. (Randy)
Back
to top
|