AQB Monitor

Today's Lineup
Sports Pages
Features
Newsstand
SPorts Links
Speak Out
Mailing List
Spotters
About Us
Home

Get 4 Risk-Free Issues of Sports Illustrated

AQB Logo

Wilcots in Spotlight as Chiefs Win Swim Meet Against Seahawks
Monday Night Blast Has Its Best Show Of The Year
ABC's Monday Night Crew Is Getting Better But The Games Aren't

Reviews from past weeks: 1 2 3 4
Click here to see reviews of this week's pregame shows

Chiefs 17 Seahawks 6

By Randy Williams

The Chiefs-Seahawks game was all wet but ESPN sideline reporter Solomon Wilcots emerged from the monsoon as a future star in Kansas City's 17-6, suspension-marred win.

During the 54-minute second-quarter weather delay, Wilcots hustled to interview Referee Phil Luckett, who assured "we'll get (the game) in." Also, he spoke with Chiefs general manager Carl Petersen after the suspension, learning that halftime would be shortened to six minutes and, if play were halted again, it would be completed during the bye week.

The former Cincinnati Bengal scored as the teams returned to field, explaining that Seattle QB Moon was late coming out for the second half because he was changing clothes, later reporting he had bruised ribs and was "questionable" to return. Shortly thereafter, he said Moon had "cracked ribs."

Mike Patrick did a good job of play-by-play under the circumstances and kept fans apprised of the weather situation, noting early that two storm systems were converging around Kansas City "and we're going to get the worst of it."

Patrick predicted that, if the rain continued, both teams would eventually move the safeties closer to the line of scrimmage, leading someone to attempt a deep pass.


Early in the second quarter, Patrick talked with Joe Theismann and Paul Maguire about how such weather affects a quarterback (Theismann) and punter (Maguire). During the delay, the trio engaged in an interesting discussion about how each team would attack the second half.

Theismann puzzled me on Kansas City's second possession. After Chiefs QB Rich Gannon lost control of the ball when he tried to stop his throwing motion, Theismann said the official ruled correctly in ruling the play an incompletion, not a fumble. Since Gannon was pulling the ball back, isn't it a fumble? We needed a clarification here.

Still, Theismann and Maguire were more than adequate, especially when talking about their past bad-weather experiences.

During the suspension, studio analyst Tom Jackson did well in noting that, in such weather conditions, "people on the periphery" become important. He said the equipment managers have the most responsibility, charged with keeping the players dry and making sure they're comfortable.

ESPN's production was fine and I really liked the "1st and Ten" technology, an imaginary yellow line which shows viewers how far the offense needs to travel to earn a first down. "1st and Ten" debuted last week when Cincinnati visited the Ravens (click here for a preview and review of the technology's debut).

Credit ESPN for a good job, especially considering the circumstances. I was particularly impressed with studio host Chris Berman, who adroitly handled the delay by showing highlights and discussing the situation with Jackson.

Top tip I: During the delay Patrick noted that commissioner Paul Tagliague is the only person with the authority to call the game.

Top observation: Patrick immediately noticing that John Friesz was in the game for Warren Moon at quarterback to start the second half. Patrick then noticed Moon returning to the sideline from the locker room.

Points for honesty: Give credit to Theismann, who chastised the Redskins, his former team, for their "lack of effort."

Best graphic: ESPN's "Misery Index," appeared during the suspension and noted 20 straight running plays, 3 fumbles, 4 punts, 3 turnovers and 5 inches of rain.

Jinx Award: As Theismann praised Gannon on Kansas City's first drive, Gannon fumbled, leading to a Seattle field goal.

Best line: "That is not a bike, it's a paddleboat," Theismann as Chiefs fullback Tony Richardson peddled a stationary bicycle.

Top stats: First-quarter graphic showed that, in the last nine seasons vs Seattle, the Chiefs are 15-3 with 64 sacks, just 23 sacks allowed and a plus-22 turnover margin.

Best picture: Shot of an extremely overweight (and shirtless) Chiefs fan, who was completely oblivious to the torrential downpour.

Grade: A, ESPN couldn't have done better under the circumstances.

Return to top
Return to main NFL page
To post a comment on our review, go to the Speak Out page.
To e-mail your opinion to Randy, click here.


Monday Night Blast

By George Stahl

This week's Monday Night Blast was easily the best of the season, mainly because it stuck to football. From Frank Gifford’s look at the friendship between Vikings receivers Randy Moss and Cris Carter to a comical look at the Packers waiting list for season tickets, Monday Night Blast was able to enlighten, inform and entertain.

Outside the Zone’s look at Moss and Carter was very good because it focused on their recent history. It showed how Carter and Moss motivate each other on and off the field. The piece didn’t go into Carter or Moss’ past, but it didn’t have to, because it was about their current relationship. Besides, their past already has been well-documented.

It was a well-done piece, highlighted by Carter’s spoken wish to make Randy Moss into the best receiver in the game by the time Carter retires.

This week’s “Bio Blast,” on Packers quarterback Brett Favre, was O.K., but I feel this segment is better utilized featuring a lesser-known subject. Most football fans probably learned little new about Favre, although give ABC credit for not using any footage from the movie “Something About Mary.”

Aww, look at how quickly our Monday Night Blast has grown up!

The Blast ended with a funny look at how long the waiting list for Packer season tickets is. It profiled a gentleman who is 13,000-something on the waiting list. Under the current pace of moving up about five places a year, the gentleman will be more than 2,500-years-old when he gets the tickets. The piece was cute and, most of all, was not a blatant advertisement for another Disney product.

Grade: B+. Monday Night Blast would have gotten an A with somebody other than Favre as the Bio.

Return to top
Return to main NFL page
To post a comment on our review, go to the Speak Out page.
To e-mail your opinion to George, click here.


Minnesota 37, Green Bay 24

By George Stahl

ABC’s Monday Night Football crew is slowly progressing into mid-season shape. Now if they could just get a good game to call that they can use as a measuring stick to see how far they have come.

For a while, I thought this week might be it; however, Minnesota broke it open in the second quarter. By the fourth quarter, Al Michaels, Dan Dierdorf and Boomer Esiason were digging for things to discuss.

In the first half, though, the threesome showed flashes of potential, especially Esiason, whose improvement from the beginning of the season is noticeable. The former quarterback noticed early on that the Packers defensive backs were having trouble keeping track of the ball and the Vikings outstanding wide receivers. This allowed the Vikings receivers to make big plays by just reacting to the ball.

That’s a good job by Esiason of noting that early and making it a theme of the broadcast. However, he didn’t take the next step and explain why the Packers defensive backs were having problems. Was it the wet field, which made it easier for Vikings receivers, who knew where the ball was going, to shake free from defenders? Are the Vikings receiver just that much bigger and better? Or did the Packers players just have a bad day?

A good announcer does what Esiason did; a great announcer takes the next step and further analyzes it.

Another thing that has become more common as the season has progressed are the debates held by Dierdorf and Esiason. I don’t know if this is a planned evolution of the MNF booth, but it is a welcomed one. Some examples from this week:

  • After Packers quarterback Brett Favre got sack on a three-step drop, Esiason suggested that offensive linemen tend to slow down after a couple seconds on plays with three-step drops. The linemen, he said, assume the quarterback has thrown the ball. Dierdorf, a Hall of Fame offensive lineman, obviously defended he comrades.
  • After a questionable roughing the passer penalty, Dierdorf snickered during the replay. To which, Esiason responded by saying, “That’s Brett Favre. Three-time MVP.” The cool part was that Esiason said that in the middle of another point that he was making, and he never broke stride in making that other point.
  • The biggest debate was about the Viking quarterback controversy. Esiason said all game that it will be hard to take Randall Cunningham out after the numbers he has put up in replacing Brad Johnson. Dierdorf, originally, said Johnson shouldn’t lose he job to injury, which is Vikings coach Dennis Green’s mantra. Dierdorf eventually backed away from that as Esiason continued to debate the topic. Then Dierdorf later said “Let’s end [the debate] with this” that some teams don’t even have one good quarterback. I think he was referring to the two teams playing at the Vet in Philadelphia on Sunday (Redskins vs. Eagles).

Esiason and Dierdorf, though, can get carried away at times. At the end of the second half, I felt they unfairly criticized the Vikings for running out the clock in the first half. The Vikings had a 24-10 lead, the ball in their own zone and a nasty rainstorm in front of them. There is no reason for the Vikings to take chances and push the ball upfield. I thought Esiason and Dierdorf were criticizing just to be critical.

As for Michaels, he was solid but not his spectacular self. He seemed a little slow on calls, but as always, he did a nice job summarizing the storylines in the game, such as the Vikings ownership situation, Randy Moss’ history and Dennis Green’s background. We haven’t heard Michaels best game yet.

Overall, the crew got silly as game went on, but you can’t blame them because they haven’t had a good game all year.

It may not have been a great game, but ABC did - and always does - have great graphics and statistics. Last night, ABC did an excellent job of keeping viewers informed of the carnage that the Vikings offense was inflicting on the Packers defense and the Packers defensive record book.

Other good graphics included:

  • a graph showing that in the Vikings-Packers rivalry, only 24 yards separated the two teams. That graphic was correct up to play that ABC showed it in the first half. Of course, it’s now more than 24 yards after the Vikings offensive explosion last night, although ABC never showed it again.
  • A chart showing Orlando Thomas has the most takeaways (24) since 1995. ABC showed the chart after a Thomas interception.
  • Coaches with the best home records. Also on the five-name list was Bill Cowher, John Madden and George Seifort.
  • A chart showing that coming into the game the Packers’ defense was No. 1 in five defensive categories.
  • And that this was the first game in eight years that had three or more touchdowns of 50 or more yards.

Other highlights and lowlights:

Good lines: 1. After Michaels noted all the Randalls on the Vikings (Cunningham, Moss, McDaniel, etc), he said he would call it a “Randy team” but randy means lecherous, lustful and Clintonlike. To which, Dierdorf responded “as you should know, [Al]”
2. Lesley Visser, after an all-too-brief interview with former Packer quarterback and Hall-of-Famer Bart Starr, “And that’s the Starr report.” I don’t even think you can call it an interview because it was only one question. And the question was actually longer than the answer.

Debate starters: 1. Esiason and Dierdorf said Vikings defensive end John Randle would be better used as a defensive tackle than as an end. (I don’t know; he seems to be doing all right on the outside.)
2. Dierdorf suggested that Denver Broncos coach Mike Shanahan is moving into the Bill Walsh offensive genius area.
3. Esiason said Dallas “is a team that would scare me” in the NFC playoffs.

Dierdorfisms: 1. “Randy Moss, you have arrived.”
2. “I think this is one of those statement games” for Randall Cunningham, Dennis Green and Vikings.
3. “Randy Moss is maybe the best young receiver” that I have ever seen.

Things that make you go hmm: 1. Esiason, “Pressure is what leads to interceptions.”
2. Esiason, “They should play flag football over there [at the Pro Bowl in February], then more players would go.” Can you tell that the ABC crew was getting desperate in trying to find things to talk about in the fourth quarter?

Commercial crazy: Monday Night Football is the worst sports telecast when it comes to commercials, and a good example why occurred at the end of the first quarter. Here’s the sequence: First quarter ends, commercial break. Second quarter begins, Packers miss on their third down play but make a field goal. Commercial break. Kickoff. Another commercial break. From the end of the first quarter to 14:46 of the second quarter, there were three commercial breaks. Atrocious.

Didja notice that...?: 1. Some unidentified person was holding the umbrella for Lesley Visser during her first report from the field after the kickoff?
2. Was Sylvester Stallone’s voice, or at least it sounded like it, on the Pontiac Bonneville commercial?
3. there were many former Eagles playing in a key role in the game, such as Reggie White, Randall Cunningham and Cris Carter? Hard to believe those Eagles teams of the early Nineties didn’t have more success. Of course, at least those Eagles teams won a game. I think I’m going to cry now.

Grade: B. ABC’s MNF crew is getting better; they just need some help from the teams.

Return to top
Return to main NFL page
To post a comment on our review, go to the Speak Out page.
To e-mail your opinion to George, click here.

 

 

Today's Lineup | Sports Pages | Features | Newsstand | Sports Links
Speak Out | Mailing List | Scouting Dept. | About Us | Home


Design & Hosting by BLAZE inter.NET